Nicola Winstanley

The art of communication- A thought experiment

The art of communication- A thought experiment

The art of communication- A thought experiment

How can I create art in the public realm that communicates clearly to it’s audience? The research project I’ve been working on over the past 2 months grew from this question and out of the anxiety that, regardless of my ability to identify what is important to people, if I can’t communicate it successfully it can have no positive effect on people. So in order to find out how best to communicate clearly to an audience in the public realm, the first thing I did was what philosophers call a ‘thought experiment’.

A thought experiment is when you try to answer a question by thinking up a realistic situation and mentally exploring all the potential consequences. The situation I thought up was this:

A man is walking around the city centre after buying some clothes and is looking for a matching jacket, all of a sudden he walks into a woman who stops him in his tracks. She is trying to offer him something, but she is speaking a foreign language. It seems quite important but he cannot understand what she is asking of him. He quickly and politely walks away apologising. Two days later he is watching the TV and flicks on to a program with someone speaking the same foreign language as the woman, remembering his encounter he flicks over quickly, reliving a little bit of the same anxiety. The weekend arrives again and the man is in the city centre to buy a present. Suddenly he is surrounded by many people all trying to get his attention but speaking the same unknown language! The man is so frustrated, he doesn’t understand why this is happening or what it is that seems so important. The man decides to avoid these people as much as possible, whatever it is they’re trying to tell him, he doesn’t want to know.

A bleak and troubling story I know! but what I was trying to do in this story was think of art as a language that not everyone understands. The negative reactions in the story are all ones I have witnessed in some people when they encounter art in the public realm; embarrassment, disengagement, frustration and avoidance.

the problem


So then I thought what could the foreign speaker (representing the artwork) do to improve communication between herself and the man? It struck me that there were 3 basic solutions.

Solution 1- Learn the man’s language

What the woman could do is learn the man’s language so he can better understand what she is offering, he can then enter into a conversation with her and they can come to a better conclusion together especially when the man understands that what the woman is offering is for his benefit.

solution 1

Back in the real world, artist and writer Dan Thompson uses this kind of solution to make his work relevant to its audience. Currently undertaking a year long residency on Stoke’s London Road, Dan is using his time to really get to know how it ticks- talking to residents & business owners, exploring the landscape, observing the way the community is. Because of this audience/location focused method, Dan has great success creating work that is of real value to the area and to it’s people.


Solution 2- Teach the man her own language

The second solution the woman could use is to teach the man her own language so he can understand what she is offering him. The upshot of this is that, once learned, he can better understand everyone else he has heard speaking that language. This solution is almost like the old proverb “Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day, teach a man to fish and he can eat for a lifetime”.

solution 2

This solution is the one that Dashyline used to create UNEARTHED, by explaining to the audience what their involvement represented and then asking them to be a part of it, it was an intrinsic part of the project that each member of the public knew exactly what the concept of the piece was. Learning a language also takes exposure and practice, and so does appreciation of art. This is why Appetite‘s 3 year program of arts in Stoke-on-Trent is hugely contributing to this learning process.


Solution 3- Demonstrate through universal gestures

The last and maybe most broadly effective method is for the woman to cut out language altogether and demonstrate her message using a gesture that anyone would understand. This would be particularly effective when the message is simple and universal itself.

solution 3

In art an example of this solution is ‘The Fallen 9000’ project by art group Sand In Your Eye, which is a WW1 memorial project that involved many people in it’s creation and when completed was unmistakable in it’s message.


I don’t think any of these methods are intrinsically better than others, I think it is at the discretion of the artist to chose which solution, or combination of solutions to use to make the best project in the circumstances. It might be useful however to consider these solutions at the start of a new project; note the differences, pros and cons, what your audience might best respond to. I know I will.


Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmailby feather

281 thoughts on “The art of communication- A thought experiment

  1. Pingback: website

  2. Pingback: opthalmologist

  3. Pingback: 15 Minute Manifestation Review

  4. Pingback: What is Motor Club Of America

  5. Pingback: wholesale shirts for printing

  6. Pingback: canli altin fiyatlari

  7. Pingback: employee login

  8. Pingback: here

  9. Pingback: Visit Website

  10. Pingback:

  11. Pingback:

  12. Pingback:

  13. Pingback: instagram hack 2

  14. Pingback: her latest blog

  15. Pingback: best womens bike helmet

  16. Pingback: شهرزاد فصل سوم قسمت دوم

  17. Pingback: emergency plumbers

  18. Pingback: porn video sites

  19. Pingback: fart

  20. Pingback: 192.168.l.l

  21. Pingback: boiler repair cricklewood

  22. Pingback: top free porn

  23. Pingback: شهرزاد سوم

  24. Pingback: شهرزاد سوم

  25. Pingback: fuck

  26. Pingback: she said

  27. Pingback: Taco Bell Headquarters Corporate Office Phone Number

  28. Pingback: فصل سوم شهرزاد چهارم

  29. Pingback: Photography Quinceañera

  30. Pingback:

  31. Pingback: فصل سوم شهرزاد قسمت چهارم

  32. Pingback: state fram

  33. Pingback: esurance home insurance

  34. Pingback: Augsburg

  35. Pingback: acid reflux remedy

  36. Pingback: melasma treatment cream

  37. Pingback: stick fight 2

  38. Pingback: transfer services

  39. Pingback:

  40. Pingback:

  41. Pingback: free porn video

  42. Pingback:

  43. Pingback: so kate louboutins

  44. Pingback: main judi dadu Hp Android

  45. Pingback: list of online business sites

  46. Pingback: Sanitär

  47. Pingback: Kendra Lust Sneaky Mom

  48. Pingback: Get More Information

  49. Pingback: check this out

  50. Pingback: Home Page

  51. Pingback: West Midlands

  52. Pingback: Withdraw Bitcoin to Bank Account

  53. Pingback: شهرزاد

  54. Pingback: live cam

  55. Pingback:

  56. Pingback: Forbidden Playground

  57. Pingback: Purple Mattress Dangerous Powder

  58. Pingback: carpet cleaning services

  59. Pingback: ventovox

  60. Pingback: OTHER E CIGARETTE

  61. Pingback:

  62. Pingback: Twitter Bots

  63. Pingback: amateur porn sites

  64. Pingback: Bourn hall clinic delhi

  65. Pingback: Bulk SMS Russian Federation

  66. Pingback: Crypto Currency

  67. Pingback:

  68. Pingback: Laptops and accessories

  69. Pingback: Asbestos Watch Sydney Service Asbestos Removal

  70. Pingback: Chilis Menu

  71. Pingback: take surveys for cash review

  72. Pingback: Headquarters

  73. Pingback: Asbestos Watch Brisbane

  74. Pingback: right here

  75. Pingback: internet

  76. Pingback: fuck tapes

  77. Pingback: white noise mp3

  78. Pingback: reputation protect

  79. Pingback: TABLE&WALL LAMP

  80. Pingback: Situs Poker

  81. Pingback: fake red bottoms for cheap

  82. Pingback: email sign in

  83. Pingback: รับทำวีซ่าเชงเก้น

  84. Pingback: More Bonuses

  85. Pingback: visit site

  86. Pingback: Travel Deals

  87. Pingback: ray ban australia afterpay

  88. Pingback: Casino Slots

  89. Pingback: Read Full Article

  90. Pingback: click here

  91. Pingback: Vibrator Sex Toys

  92. Pingback: Online Pokies Australia

  93. Pingback: beleza cosmeticos

  94. Pingback: PDF Files

  95. Pingback:

  96. Pingback: Discover More Here

  97. Pingback: Interior Design Ideas

  98. Pingback: sell my house fast lancaster

  99. Pingback: los angeles reverse mortgage

  100. Pingback: accidente de carro abogado

  101. Pingback: wedding photographer CT

  102. Pingback: hard inquiry removal letter

  103. Pingback: MILF Amber Jayne What's Good For The Goose

  104. Pingback: pc homew Make Millions

  105. Pingback: Pot O'Dongs Eva Notty Carolina Sweets

  106. Pingback: kunt

  107. Pingback: Pussy Pressure Points Julia Ann

  108. Pingback: Cheap Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys

  109. Pingback: over here

  110. Pingback: Home Page

  111. Pingback: iamtheceo

  112. Pingback: matthew pillmore

  113. Pingback: listen to this podcast

  114. Pingback: screwing

  115. Pingback: replica christian louboutin clutch bags

  116. Pingback:

  117. Pingback: wnetrza

  118. Pingback: Ringhotel Loew's Merkur

  119. Pingback: orgas

  120. Pingback: instagram mass unfollow

  121. Pingback:

  122. Pingback: drone works ny

  123. Pingback: escort in lahore

  124. Pingback: Internação Involuntária

  125. Pingback: large personal loans

  126. Pingback: siófok taxi

  127. Pingback: click for more info

  128. Pingback: website here

  129. Pingback: Resources

  130. Pingback: bungee run hire

  131. Pingback: ตัวแทนขายรถ

  132. Pingback: Get More Information

  133. Pingback: cash till payday

  134. Pingback: วิธีทําให้ผิวขาว

  135. Pingback: locksmith

  136. Pingback: plumber in savannah ga

  137. Pingback: The Red Tea Detox

  138. Pingback: acer aspire v5-132 drivers for windows 7 32 bit

  139. Pingback: Manifestation Miracle Review

  140. Pingback: fruit shopping bag

  141. Pingback: www ray ban canada

  142. Pingback: Full Article

  143. Pingback: weblink

  144. Pingback: can i get a loan with bad credit

  145. Pingback: dildo

  146. Pingback:

  147. Pingback:

  148. Pingback: montaj aer conditionat

  149. Pingback: mother

  150. Pingback: wilhelm willeke balmaceda

  151. Pingback: stream movies

  152. Pingback: weblink

  153. Pingback: drugs

  154. Pingback: Reiko

  155. Pingback: Dong

  156. Pingback: Daine

  157. Pingback: jizz

  158. Pingback: Mabelle

  159. Pingback:

  160. Pingback:

  161. Pingback:

  162. Pingback:

  163. Pingback: wedding dresses Toronto

  164. Pingback: price comparison

  165. Pingback: Olen Potocki

  166. Pingback: Argueta

  167. Pingback: next page

  168. Pingback: montaj aer conditionat preturi

  169. Pingback:

  170. Pingback: the general insurance quote

  171. Pingback: Forbrugslån

  172. Pingback: Fake Oakley Frogskins Sunglasses

  173. Pingback: discoteche versilia

  174. Pingback: drugs

  175. Pingback: fat loss

  176. Pingback:

  177. Pingback: low carb diet

  178. Pingback: belly fat burning drinks

  179. Pingback: lose body fat in just 21 days

  180. Pingback: Website

  181. Pingback: Ivo ignatov site

  182. Pingback: Neha

  183. Pingback: Malayalam

  184. Pingback: Viagra Sans Ordonnance

  185. Pingback: KLIK

  186. Pingback: Look At This

  187. Pingback: KLIK

  188. Pingback:

  189. Pingback: top selling board games of all time

  190. Pingback: Nâng Mũi S Line

  191. Pingback: amolatina

  192. Pingback: michael kors hamilton bag outlet

  193. Pingback: boff

  194. Pingback: Exchange Cryptocurrency to US Dollars

  195. Pingback: clubs barcelona

  196. Pingback: it asset disposal

  197. Pingback: computer equipment disposal

  198. Pingback: old it disposal

  199. Pingback: it asset disposal

  200. Pingback: best clubs barcelona

  201. Pingback: exposed skin care system

  202. Pingback: Phẫu Thuật Hàm Hô Bao Nhiêu Tiền

  203. Pingback: go here

  204. Pingback: jake burgess springfield mo

  205. Pingback: leaking roof

  206. Pingback: gepi site

  207. Pingback: page address

  208. Pingback: Elliott Wave WXY Pattern

  209. Pingback: watch this video

  210. Pingback: saham ciputra

  211. Pingback: Rich Fucks Part 2 Bridgette B Kristen Scott Honey Gold Xander Corvus

  212. Pingback: blog

  213. Pingback: Going In Blind Ella Hughes Gina Valentina Preston Parker

  214. Pingback: stormy's secret stormy daniels keiran lee

  215. Pingback: Amia Miley Catching Amia's Ass Bounce on POV

  216. Pingback: Porn Star Sex Tips 2 Luna Star Markus Dupree

  217. Pingback: Richelle Ryan Christening The Cougar

  218. Pingback: Bernardina

  219. Pingback: styrker koncentrationen

  220. Pingback: www

  221. Pingback: jimmy choo

  222. Pingback: Ambika Ahuja Jaipur Escorts

  223. Pingback: Oaklay Sunglass

  224. Pingback: MAC

  225. Pingback: Neha Tyagi MODEL JAIPUR ESCORTS



  228. Pingback: Dhruvi Jaipur Escorts Service


  230. Pingback: Jiya Malik High Profile Jaipur Escorts Model




  234. Pingback: Selly Arora Independent Bangalore Escorts

  235. Pingback: Enjoy With Jaipur Escorts Tanisha Walia


  237. Pingback: Bristy Roy Independent Bangalore Escorts


  239. Pingback: Bangalore Escorts Sneha Despandey


  241. Pingback: XXX PORN Radhika Apte Model Escort

  242. Pingback: jake burgess springfield mo

  243. Pingback: web-site

  244. Pingback: oakley mx goggles australia

  245. Pingback: telugu movies download

  246. Pingback: taxi siofok

  247. Pingback: recomiendame una puta

  248. Pingback: Read Full Article

  249. Pingback: business

  250. Pingback: fag

  251. Pingback: taken from here

  252. Pingback: Look At This

  253. Pingback: buy viagra

  254. Pingback: I thought about this

  255. Pingback: racing biker clothing in uk

  256. Pingback: Promotional products australia

  257. Pingback: puss

  258. Pingback: blog post

  259. Pingback: discount canada goose coats

  260. Pingback: drone works zac

  261. Pingback: matthew pillmore

  262. Pingback: aaron woodman real estate

  263. Pingback: travel social

  264. Pingback: Do you think you might have herpes?

  265. Pingback: quality B&W

  266. Pingback:

  267. Pingback: I was reading this

  268. Pingback: Apache ZooKeeper

  269. Pingback: continue

  270. Pingback: go

  271. Pingback: click to go

  272. Pingback: click to find out more

  273. Pingback: just click for source

  274. Pingback: System reviews

  275. Pingback: discoteche versilia

  276. Pingback: capodanno versilia

  277. Pingback: elvis impersonator

  278. Pingback: House for sale in Oak lawn, IL.

  279. Pingback: copywriter

  280. Pingback: Best Sex Hookup Members 30031

  281. Pingback: bigg boss 12 watch online